If you're saying you have tried "Movie Time", I'm guessing that you are in the NY area. We have one active poster who supplies cars for projects in that area, Axl_Rosenberg, who is partner in Lost Soul Entertainment. They seem to be one of the main companies in that area.

Movie Time has changed their website recently, so you have to be registered to search it for the most part. I tried looking up your Subaru and it didn't show up in the search.

I find more cars listed on Creative Film Cars that are used in productions. But it's still thousands of cars that any producer would have to search through.