Answer :: IMCDb Forum

Send an answer to a topic: The USA wants to copy the German "Abwrackprämie" for cars

Warning, this subject is old (5556 days without answer)

Subject
forum_emoticons.html	[quote=ingo,29971]http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/0,1518,618322,00.html They write, that the US-government had such plans before, but the lobbyist's group SEMA had reached, that they were cancelled. Now President Obama will start it again. Of the 250 million cars in the USA are 30% older than 15 years. So 75 millon cars shall be worth to crush. The US-plan is a bit different than the German one (here you get 2500 € for cars, vans and campmobiles older than 9 years). The US-plan is meant for cars with have a fuel consumtion of more than 18 mpg (for Europeans: more than 13 liters on 100 km). The goventment-paid bonus shall shall be between 2500 and 4500 $. A politician of the Democrats, Betty Sutton suggests a bonus of 5000 $, when you buy a North American made car. There is such a bonus-system still active in Texas (but only in the areas of Houston, Dallas and Austin). There you get up to 3500 $ for wrecking an older car - but the problem is, that nearly all of these people are buying used cars from this money. O.K., it's a problem of Texas, how they made their rules. So you US-guys over here, perhaps soon you can see overfilled junkyards and shredder-machines, who are working day and night - as we Germans right now (and in the early 90ies after the GDR-collapsing) and the French some years before.[/quote]
	Options
	Receive notification of answer to this topic by email
	Analyse text for smileys
	Analyse text for BBCode

ingo

As to be expected:
http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/unternehmen/0,1518,652716,00.html

Since the Abwrackprämie was dropped out, the selling of cars in Germany was broken down on 50%. Similar in the USA, where the "cash for clunkers"-bonus has ended, too.

So today the car-companies and -dealers have the same problems as before again.

ingo

A Youtube about cars, which were actually crushed over her:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a9sZ4GF9_oM

ingo

@taxiguy: the same, as you wrote, we have thought in Germany, too. It was the opinion of the majority. But what had happened shortly later? It was a real hype, sometimes the people were getting hysterical about that. They only have seen, that they can get 2500 € from the government.
So until now 1.2 million (or even 1.4 million?) cars were wrecked about this "Abwrackprämie".
The most inscription-forms were written and sent to the authority, so the paperwork is getting less, but still you can see a plenty old old cars, delivered to the dealers for wrecking.

A friend from the K 70-club, who works at a VW-dealer, has told me, that at the beginning of this offer, they had a real line-up with dozens of cars up on the street to their shop. The customers were really mad, not to be too late. They had to organize a coffee-bar and have given out numbers to have a system for the organization. :ohwell:

But he has said, that there was no reason to be sad or mad as an old-car-fan, they didn't get any real classic for wrecking. Some really good Golf II or Audi 80 from the 80ies, too good for wrecking, but not real oldtimers.

Here the actual clip of Volkswagen:
http://www.horizont.net/kreation/tv/pages/protected/show.php?id=2546
The Golf II-fans are a bit pissed about it.

Oh, and I just have found a new pic of this campaign:
http://www.onetoone.de/homepage/VW_Abschied_nehmen_lohnt_sich_16022.html
A girl with a Daewoo Nexia. She wrote "Machs gut, Alter" - "So long, Oldie" with lipstick on the front screen.

taxiguy

It won't work as well as they want it to no doubt. Only a few people are actually going to do it. It is really only good for people on the fence about getting a new car, it won't sway people who hadn't even thought about buying new. Even with the voucher people will still have to come up with 10-20k dollars, and no one has that to spend (and certainly not the kind of people being targeted). It is rather stupid and will likely be a huge flop like in a couple of other places that have tried it.

If they were giving away 4,500 dollars CASH instead of a new car voucher, than it would be a completely different story. But of course they're not doing that...

They originally wanted to get 500,000 cars, but many are saying they will struggle to get even 200,000 because the law is so restricted. Just pointless and stupid is what it is.

ingo

As I just read in the news, the "cash for clunkers"-law, as it's called in the USA, has passed the Congress. 250 000 cars shall be wrecked now.

I've learned a new word: clunkers. Funny, that we use it in German, too, but with annother meaning - a flippant term for diamonds and jewlery. :smile:

antp

indeed my garage is 4.4m long, too short for a XM
XM found for cheap are common. It is sad but lots are wrecked like that in France :ohwell:

taxiguy

I don't think he can buy an XM, as he said previously it won't fit in his garage. (hard to belive yes, as his garge would have to be the size of a bathroom to not fit a little 185 inch long XM) :grin:

ingo

@Antoine: today I've seen in the backyard of our local Fiat/Alfa/Lancia-dealer, where the "Abwrackprämie"-cars are stored, a Citroen XM. It's dark red and has a "V6"-sign on the front fender.

Are you interested? You wrote, that you would like to have a XM.

Yes, I know, that it's not legally to buy and register it again - but here in Germany. As I know, you can make half-legal tricks to export these cars, dedicated for the shredder.
The owner of the Fiat-garage is a nice guy, perhaps I can arrange something for you. :wink:

You only must see, how to register it again in Belgium without papers. I guess, it should be possible anyhow (at least make something with the FIN-no... :wink:

)

ingo

@Gag: better don't think, that the public opinion will stay like this.

At the start of the German Abwrackprämie there were also several articles like this, even full net-blogs of people with this opinion.

But what had happen, when it was running? A kind of national hystery!
Noone had expected that.

Thousands of people have lost their rationality. They only see "2500 € from the government! I want to have it know!"
So this is the reason, why a lot of cars were scrapped, which have a higher value than 2500 €. And many people, which normally cannot afford money for a new car, are having now high credits just for this reason (and a lot of them will not be able to pay all the debts back).

So just wait, until this British scrappage-regulation will be released. You will be wondering, how crazy the people will react.

Gag Halfrunt

There's an article in today's Guardian arguing that the British scrappage scheme won't be popular:

Trashing my 940 estate and taking the scrappage incentive simply doesn't add up. I'd have to buy a new car and it would have to be big enough to cart at least 20 bags of peat-free compost from the local B&Q or a load of camping gear and a few bikes. About the cheapest cars you can buy on the £2,000 voucher are the Hyundai i10 at £7,000 and the £6,195 Kia Picanto. But they're out of the question – too small and lacking the tank-like build of my Volvo.

A new Volvo equivalent to mine has a sticker price of £25,400. The scrappage scheme rules say you have to buy a new car, not "nearly new" or with "delivery mileage", so the usual discounts for canny buyers are not available. Even one reduced to £23,400 after the scrappage deal would clean out my bank balance many times over.

I could go for a cheaper make but I'm still looking at big money. In any case, my colleague Miles Brignall tells me car makers have been quietly pushing up prices by between £750 and £1,500 in expectation of the scheme. So the trade's £1,000 is covered by higher prices, while the government will get its £1,000 back (and more) in VAT on the new car. It's a fair bet dealers will see me coming with my voucher. So I won't get a bargain.